Sep 03, 2015 tony abbott has rejected criticism from the jewish community for comparing isis to the nazis, restating that unlike previous evildoers such as stalin and hitler, isis boasts added a. Oct 30, 2018 the nazi werewolves who terrorized allied soldiers at the end of wwii though the guerrilla fighters didnt succeed in slowing the allied occupation of germany, they did sow fear wherever they went. This destruction of historical memory is soooo typical for patrons of kiev junta and isis vatican and israel respectively. Tony abbott has been taken to task after suggesting islamic state terrorists are more evil than the nazis the prime minister made the contentious comments in a. Btw, i have it on good authority from this news blog that before hitler, there were only 20 jews in all of germany, austria and poland. One of the main reasons is the crackdown on isis, led by twitter shutting down 360,000 accounts. Tony abbott defends comparison between isis and nazis. And in terms of their mercilessness and sheer pride in butchering men, women and children, it. Holocaust investigator on parallel between nazis and isis. Preserving christianity in the place of its birth and in. The most popular theme for alternative histories by far is world war ii it would have been possible to populate the entire list with books where the nazis won or the conflicts outcome is drastically different. Paul iddon, journalist based in iraqi kurdistan in the summer of 2014, the islamic state isis group dominated international headlines following.
The thing that stuck in my mind was that the tone, phrases, attitudes, etc of the book were of the winner writes history slant which would be. Nazi germany can only use weapons and supplies from their time. Did hitler has a chance to win world war ii matisaks. And if the nazis did not invaid the soviet union they would have ww2. Why, really, the nazis won the war and how they did it. Currently, some fighters from volunteer battalions in ukraine take photos with isis flags and sympathize with them. Kurdish forces seized control of the syrian town of kobani in january 2015 after a fourmonth battle with islamic state fighters. A typical comment came from senator elizabeth warren. Parallels between isis and nazis revealed in christian ghetto rebel staff as part of our mission to iraq, i visited the ancient christian cemetery in telskuf, iraq, which has been desecrated by isis. Sep 14, 2014 isis is unlike anything the world has seen since the nazis. Now lets look at the amount of land the nazis controlled at their prime. The majority of scholars identify nazism in both theory and practice as a form of farright politics.
Isis tactics are similar to nazi germanys realcleardefense. Apr 27, 2015 nazi germany is brought to the present and all of the militaries fighting isis will stop fighting them thanks to rob. Isis bears some striking similarities to the nazis, even if it differs in significant ways. When i say that really, the nazis won the war, i dont mean nazi as figurative term or as a general term to describe fascists or authoritarians. Feb 28, 2017 isis barbarians are teaching fighters to eat their enemies if food supplies run low, experts claim neonazi teen cleared teen, 17, who hailed jo coxs murderer a fing legend escapes jail. What would the world look like if we defeated isis. It aimed to overcome social divisions and create a german homogeneous society based on racial purity which represented a peoples community volksgemeinschaft.
Nov 04, 2016 a copy of the book in which the nazi leader outlines his hatred for jews and bolsheviks and plans for an allconquering germany was seized from an isis leader in the sinai area of egypt. Its important to realize there is only few thousands of active nazis in ukraine mostly football hooligans by origin but millions of roman catholics branded in many ways in. The undisputed king of alternative histories is the prolific harry turtledove, who has helped guide the genre into mainstream reading. Isis barbarians are teaching fighters to eat their enemies if food supplies run low, experts claim neonazi teen cleared teen, 17, who hailed jo coxs murderer a fing legend escapes jail. Basically the nazis with only 3 valkyria start going on the offensive again despite the allies numbers and weapon superiority until the allies start developing their own valkyria which leads to the. Sep 03, 2015 tony abbott has been taken to task after suggesting islamic state terrorists are more evil than the nazis the prime minister made the contentious comments in a 2gb interview with newscaster alan. He looks around him and he knows that theres a direct line between what the nazis did more than 70 years ago and what isis is doing today, goldberg says. A copy of the book in which the nazi leader outlines his hatred for jews and bolsheviks and plans for an allconquering germany was seized from an isis leader in the sinai area of egypt. Naziobsessed isis warlords immerse themselves in adolf.
Luther pierce, has inspired more than 200 murders since its publication in. After the almost 100 percent defeat of isis, what about its ideology. Unlike isis, the nazis had three allies and isis had none. Mujahid has a swastika tattooed on his body and he also likes to take pictures with iblis devil state state flag. A twitter post thursday by supporters of the islamic state of iraq and syria isis, now calling itself the islamic state is, has promised a holocaust against the jews. Antisemitic propaganda was a common theme in nazi propaganda. Jihadisms global civil war, the national interest februarymarch 2015. The best alternative histories in literature on abebooks. Everyone in the world will ignore nazi germany except for. Germany invades isis with the normal placemet of countries round 2. Mar 21, 2019 a typical comment came from senator elizabeth warren. Empire vs ww2 germany valkyria chronicles 4 message. A christian genocide at the hands of islamic extremists is unfolding in the middle east.
Sep 28, 2015 mark riebling has been an architect of post911 intelligencedriven policing, cofounding and serving as research director for the center for policing terrorism. Watch the video of altright excuse me, fucking goddamn nazis praising fuhrer trump and making nazi salutes and questioning the humanity of jews and liberals, and then try to tell me that racism isnt what got that orange asshole elected. Isis would have present day technology vs the nazis from 1942 onwards. So, lets say the nazis conquered syria and own the place.
Isis is getting gunned down, hands in the air or not. Farright, neonazi, white supremacism, extremism, terrorism, atomwaffen. Worse for the nazis, they had too few soldiers to prevent larger breakthroughs by the soviet, american and british armies the following year. Isis is unlike anything the world has seen since the nazis. The nazi werewolves who terrorized allied soldiers at the end. His days of infamy books have japan occupying hawaii. Winner of the 2014 fraenkel prize in contemporary history in the most crucial phase of the second world war, german troops, fighting in regions as far apart as. The nazis meant to cause fear through intimidation and discipline. Nazis had an entire country, an advanced airforcenavy and army, and were very close to creating an atomic bomb. Besides, sooner or later isis will fall one way or another, meanwhile if the cartels survive this thunderdome, they will still be an integral part of the americas. The clear advantage enjoyed by white nationalists was attributable in part to the effects of aggressive suspensions of accounts associated with isis networks. And in terms of their mercilessness and sheer pride in butchering men, women and children, it is even outdoing the nazis.
Tony abbott has rejected criticism from the jewish community for comparing isis to the nazis, restating that unlike previous evildoers such as stalin and hitler, isis boasts added a. A comparative study of white nationalist and isis online social media networks, white nationalists and nazi sympathizers are winning over more followers than isis by a landslide. Tony abbott riduculed for saying isis is worse than the nazis. Nazis win easily with the sole caveat of allowing these groups to prep in our modern world and purchase mercenaries and ordinance from kim jong. I mean the actual original nazis of the 3rd reich from 1933 1945 in germany, the leaders of the nsdap translated as the national socialist german workers party, as distinct from the rankand. Nov 11, 2015 the ideology of isis will eventually meet its end like that of the nazis did. Well, yes, and thats nazi zombies, but luckily were not dealing with any master race zombies. If we analyze the relationships between isis and ukrainian neonazis, we find many common points. The nazi werewolves who terrorized allied soldiers at the. Isis, nazis and the ideology of hate robert rozett the. Nazism subscribed to pseudoscientific theories of racial hierarchy and social darwinism, identifying the germans as a part of what the nazis regarded as an aryan or nordic master race. President obama says that isis will not be defeated with guns but better ideas.
The nazis were totalitarian monsters, but at least they believed in something, no matter how evil. The turner diaries, the infamous racist dystopian novel by neonazi william. If isis and the mexican cartels would go to war, who would. Hows this different than all the islamic militant groups. Jul 04, 2014 a twitter post thursday by supporters of the islamic state of iraq and syria isis, now calling itself the islamic state is, has promised a holocaust against the jews. Aug 19, 2017 nazi rallies, spreading hate against americans. Tony abbott defends comparison between isis and nazis after. Studies of isis activity, while useful, examine only a fraction of the violent extremist landscape. Isil, kievs nazis, and the rage against history the. So if isis is just like the nazis, that would mean if the usa went to war against isis, we would be totally righteous in doing so, right. If isis magically wipe out the cartels, it probably saves more life than wiping out isis.
Agent of byzantium has the byzantine empire surviving. Jul 21, 2008 i seem to remember somebody mentioning a what if fiction book that looked back at wwii after the fact, written as if germany had won wwii. How hitler could have won world war ii by bevin alexander. Isis would have present day technology vs the nazis. Lets say that 1940s nazi germany wanted to invade the islamic caliphate. Whether armenia, the nazis or isis if youre going to commit. Nazi germany is the aggressor and isis has to defend its land. White nationalist terrorism has increasingly been tied. But the biggest challenge is what kind of peace we want when we win. Farright themes in nazism include the argument that superior people have a right to dominate other people and purge society of supposed inferior elements.
Sep 11, 2017 on 5 may 1945, a few days after hitlers suicide, american soldiers under command of us army captain john c. Abbott argued that the nazi death cult at least tried to keep their slaughters secret or play them down. Turkey is the battleground, germany has all of its wonder weapons and state of the art equipment up to its defeat, and isis has teamed up with assad, hamas, and the taliban in a no holds barred war over the country of turkey. A dataset of white nationalist accounts was created from the followers of accounts for the most. A member loyal to the isis waves an isis flag in raqqa 3774 iraq crisis iraqi antigovernment gunmen from sunni tribes in the western anbar province march during a protest in ramadi, west of baghdad. Isis, communism, and the lure of violent utopianism. Ideas are all well and good, but wars are won in the material world. I seem to remember somebody mentioning a what if fiction book that looked back at wwii after the fact, written as if germany had won wwii. If we look at the nazis tactics for intimidation and fear, we can see that theyre very good at it. America, iran and the struggle for the middle east.
The nazi werewolves who terrorized allied soldiers at the end of wwii though the guerrilla fighters didnt succeed in slowing the allied occupation of germany, they. He received his degree in philosophy from the university of california at berkeley and is the author of wedge. The nazi werewolves who terrorized allied soldiers at the end of. Mark riebling has been an architect of post911 intelligencedriven policing, cofounding and serving as research director for the center for policing terrorism. However, it was occasionally reduced for tactical reasons, such as for the 1936 olympic games. The thing that stuck in my mind was that the tone, phrases, attitudes, etc of the book were of the winner writes history slant which would be so odd to us today. In the same way that isis and alqaeda terrorism pose a threat to the u. Sure, isis has yet to achieve the military capabilities of nazi germany in the 1940s.
Australian prime minister tony abbott shocked many when he said that isis are actually worse than the nazis due to their desire to publicise the gruesome slaughters they carry out, according to sky news. The nazis only did a few mistakes to lose ww2, and killed more people. Apr 29, 2015 1 this testimony draws heavily on my work with jennifer r. Adolf hitler and other proponents denied that nazism was either leftwing or rightwing. Nazi germany vs isis please excuse the formatting i am on mobile. The real zionist holocaust is predicted in the hadiths. Because world war ii against the nazis was a just war, you see. Nazis on twitter homeland security digital library. The exclusivist new world order isis wants to create is not based on race, but on a fanatical variety of. Isis, nazis and the ideology of hate robert rozett the blogs. The number of its victims is alsoat least so farminuscule in comparison to wwii.
Nazi germany is brought to the present and all of the militaries fighting isis will stop fighting them thanks to rob. Theres a comic book called uber that is 100% basically what if nazi germany in 1945 had valkyria as they operate in pretty much the exact same way. For starters, lets just take a look at the land area isisisildaesh had at the peak of its existence. On 5 may 1945, a few days after hitlers suicide, american soldiers under command of us army captain john c. Isis, for now, is a footnote to what we learned in the 20th century about how fragile civilization is. The ideology of isis will eventually meet its end like that of the nazis did. The fourth reich comparing isis to the nazis is totally necessary for the mediagovernment. In his first state of the union address in january 2018, president donald trump declared isis militarily defeated, and reminded the congress of.
We know, for example, that hitlers third reich supported the muslim brotherhood as a weapon against the british in egypt and throughout the middle east. After the paris attacks, the french can impel nato to attack isis. Jan 29, 2017 alternatively, if hitler had won world war ii and then exercised a nationalist sphere of influence over the greater western world, wed have a more just, fair, and moral western world today. In january, kurdish troops launched a major offensive that broke islamic states lines in northern iraq. Theyre just run of the mill terrorist scum with a little extra training. Isis supporters had better discipline regarding consistent use of the movements hashtags, but trailed in virtually every other respect.
The guns of the south has the confederates equipped with ak47s by. From an acclaimed military historian, a fascinating account of just how close the allies were to losing world war ii. Nazis win easily with the sole caveat of allowing these groups to prep in our modern world and purchase. Aug 12, 2014 isis bears some striking similarities to the nazis, even if it differs in significant ways. Isis an alqaidatype of the greatest ferocity and religious bigotry, as cockburn says, went on to claim the creation of a sunni caliphate spanning much of iraq. More numerous, better organization, tanks, planes, bigger bombs.
His southern victory or timeline191 series has the confederates beating the union. The only way isis can win is if they find a nuke and use it on the germans first, barring that its a 9. Its important to realize there is only few thousands of active nazis in ukraine mostly football hooligans by origin but millions of roman catholics branded in many ways in their most vicious form. Nazi germany will go to war with the idlamic state using 193945 tech. Though the guerrilla fighters didnt succeed in slowing the allied occupation of germany, they did sow fear wherever they went. Isis are the modern nazis, and their leader is the new. Do you think nazi germany had a chance to win wwii and if not why and if yes under. A forgotten episode of world war ii, the supreme court case it sparked, and the precedent it set. Isis isnt the first group thats been compared to the nazis. Isis dont have the technology or following to pull off what the nazis did. My wifes father, my uncles, my grandfather fought in a brutal war to end that fascism, and now the republican party has brought them to power here. The sun isnt the only voice making the controversial isisnazis comparison.
How do you organise a successful genocide in turkish armenia a century ago, in nazioccupied europe in the 1940s, or in the middle east. Isis replaces denmark and invades germany in a manner that the maximum ammount of border is shared. The rest of the world would have similarly benefited had the germans been victorious since german influence would have surely spread elsewhere. Did hitler and his close associates really believe the third reich can achieve the lasting global dominance. It was a recurring topic in hitlers book mein kampf 192526, which was a key component of nazi ideology early in his membership in the nazi party, hitler presented the jews as behind all of germanys moral and.
1281 1333 140 872 1261 122 549 1305 874 19 51 1307 1520 1386 293 424 771 1556 613 340 859 1020 928 914 93 1147 1270 543 1085 105 1041 982 366 504 66 1168 489 1401 701 1040 816 493